Articles | Commonfund | Asset Management

Thinking Outside the Benchmark

Written by Mark J.P. Anson | Nov 1, 2024 1:00:00 PM

Twenty years ago, Mark authored an article published in The Journal of Portfolio Management titled "Thinking Outside the Benchmark" to describe a new way of pension fund management. He concluded the following: 

  1. Pension plans need to eliminate the restrictions associated with traditional asset allocation.
  2. Traditional asset allocation models partition the financial markets into convenient benchmark boxes, but these boxes can inhibit alpha extraction.
  3. Look for investment opportunities that fall between the benchmark boxes of traditional asset allocation and are driven by economic factors rather than asset class descriptions.
  4. Pension funds should deemphasize their investment organizational structure along traditional asset class lines. Build teams of investment staff that bridge asset classes.
  5. Consider the risk of peer group underperformance. Strict asset allocation reduces the risk of underperformance compared with standard benchmarks, but it also reduces the opportunity to outperform  a peer group. 
  6. Focus of the total return of the pension portfolio rather than individual asset classes. 

Read more on how these concepts are incorporated into a framework today known as the total portfolio approach or TPA in the full article.