Insights Blog

Behind the thrift store: Goodwill and nonprofit investment policy

Written by Commonfund Institute | November 18, 2026

 

Most people know Goodwill from the donation bin or the store down the street. Fewer know that behind every local Goodwill is an independent nonprofit making real decisions about how to invest and manage the capital that funds its job training and community programs — decisions that, until recently, had no real peer benchmark.

The inaugural Commonfund Study of Goodwill Organizations Investment Pools was built to close that benchmark gap. Commonfund Institute partnered with Goodwill Industries International and Goodwill Kentucky to survey Goodwill organizations across the country on how they manage two distinct pools of capital: long-term, endowment-style assets meant to sustainably fund programs for decades, and short-term operating reserves that enable the organizations to serve the local communities on a daily basis.

Why it matters

As each Goodwill is independently governed, there's no shared investment office or playbook. One organization's approach to spending, asset allocation, or debt can look very different from another's. Until now, there were few ways for boards and finance leaders to know whether their own practices were in line with peers facing the same mission-driven pressures.

What we found, broadly

The results paint a picture of solid fundamentals paired with real room to grow. Participating organizations are largely disciplined about how they invest for the long term, with strong governance practices around their investment policies. Short-term reserves, as you'd expect, are managed conservatively and built for liquidity and safety rather than growth. At the same time, the data revealed some clear opportunities, particularly around formalizing spending policies and strengthening governance practices for short-term pools.

The response has been clear: this kind of peer benchmarking fills a real gap. We're grateful to the 13 Goodwill organizations that made this inaugural study possible, and we're already looking ahead to growing participation in future editions, so every Goodwill organization has a genuine peer benchmark to measure against.

Join the 2026 study

Nonprofit investing doesn’t come with a shared playbook, and a benchmark is only as strong as the organizations behind it. Every Goodwill that participates makes the results more useful for every board and finance team.

What participating organizations receive

    • A complimentary copy of the full study showing how Goodwill organizations manage both long-term, endowment-style assets and short-term operating reserves
    • Data and insights on how Goodwill organizations manage long-term and short-term assets, so you can conduct your own peer comparison of spending policy, asset allocation and use of debt
    • Governance benchmarks for investment policies, including short-term pools, where the 2026 results showed the most room to grow
    • Confidentiality: individual responses are never identified, and results are reported only in aggregate

Why participate

Without a benchmark, boards are left guessing whether their practices are in line with peers. Participation gives your board and finance leaders data to inform spending decisions, strengthen policies and support their fiduciary oversight.

How to participate

The 2026 Commonfund Study of Goodwill Organizations launches in spring 2027. To take part, click here and we’ll send participation details as the launch approaches.