Nonprofit Hospitals - Big Business in Nonprofit Clothing?

June 17, 2019 |
3 minute read
|

In the last few months, high profile nonprofit institutions have come under intense scrutiny for ethical dilemmas pertaining to the stewardship of resources meant to support mission. This is Part Two in our three-part series of thought pieces, in which the Commonfund Institute will contemplate ever evolving ethical considerations among nonprofit institutions pulled right from current events. See Part One here.

A majority of hospitals in the United States operate as nonprofit organizations and are exempt from most federal, state, and local taxes. In addition to tax exemptions, nonprofit status allows hospitals to benefit from tax-exempt bond financing and to receive charitable contributions that are tax-deductible to donors. This favorable tax status is intended to promote and acknowledge the community benefit provided by these institutions.1

Historically, the vast majority of hospital community benefits is charity care, providing patients care services for free or a reduced charge. Charity care is only one type of community benefit that nonprofit hospitals provide, and not all health systems calculate charity care the same way. The federal definition of community benefit provides hospitals with tremendous latitude, and state and local governments have their own laws that vary substantially from state to state, making the definition and requirements regarding the provision of community benefits variable.2

Over time, some nonprofit hospitals, originally set up to serve the poor, a clear community benefit, have been transformed by shifting market forces to resemble for profit businesses. Many larger nonprofit hospital systems have seen earnings soar in recent years, riding gains from investment portfolios and enjoying the pricing power that came from a decade of mergers. In 2018, NBC News reported that the largest nonprofit hospitals earned a collective $21 billion in investment income.3 Although that number is astonishing, many smaller/rural nonprofit hospitals operate in the red, and without income from investable pools to help mitigate the loss of patient revenue, they struggle to keep their doors open.

With the passage of the Affordable Care Act (ACA), healthcare continues to change rapidly, as the landscape shifts from fee for service to a value-based system. A focus on population health, a shift of care into ambulatory, virtual, and community-based settings, and increased competition from non-traditional competitors are just some of the economic and regulatory forces creating critical strategic, operating, and financial challenges for health and hospital systems.

These changes mean that larger nonprofit hospital systems need diverse revenue streams to remain viable, but there has been public controversy over whether they provide community benefits sufficient to justify the tax exemptions. Over the years, several states, including, Illinois, Michigan, New Jersey, and Wisconsin have waged battles with large nonprofit hospitals over tax exemption. Recently Pittsburgh Attorney General Josh Shapiro accused University of Pittsburgh Medical Center (UPMC), a major nonprofit hospital system and health insurer, of failing to fulfill its charitable mission.4

The legal challenge rests on the accusation that UPMC, which offers health insurance and health care, has not been acting like a true charity, in violation of state law that makes it tax-exempt and helped it avoid $40 million in property taxes last year alone. The Attorney General stated that “practices such as requiring out-of-network patients to pay for care before receiving treatment run counter to its charitable mission.” The UPMC legal battle also highlights the ethical question of whether powerful nonprofit hospital systems that receive benefits as charities, such as millions of dollars in tax breaks and public and private donations, should be more explicitly held accountable for providing more community benefits.

Studies have shown that some nonprofit hospitals do not act like nonprofits, especially when the economy is doing poorly. As nonprofit hospital’s finances get more challenging, they may not be willing to offer services that are less profitable but greatly needed, like emergency psychiatric care or obstetrics.5  Additional research indicates that although calculated percentages of community benefit vary by hospitals, the mixed results are proof that the notion of community benefit needs to be reexamined and made clearer to ensure it is commensurate with the tax benefits provided.6

The changing landscape of healthcare and the incentives (or disincentives) provided to large nonprofit hospital systems arguably make it more and more difficult to focus on the mission of providing high quality patient care to those in need. As the lines between behaving like a big business and being a nonprofit become more blurred, hospital boards of trustees will need to use ethical frameworks in addition to financial, operational, and strategic tools to more effectively find balance between profitability and providing continued, high impact community benefit. Fundamentally, a more profound ethical consideration is how do we, as a society, ensure that resources are being deployed equitably across our healthcare system so that everyone has access to timely, high quality care?

1 Health Affairs, 2/25/2016, Julia James, Nonprofit Hospitals’ Community Benefit Requirements

2 Hilltop Institute, Community Benefit State Law Profiles

3 NBC News, 2/7/2018, Hospitals made $21B on Wall Street last year, but are patients seeing those profits?

4 The Washington Post, Feb 2019, Giant Hospital system’s charity status challenged

5 US National Library of Medicine, National Institutes of Health, Published Feb. 2018, Herring, Gaskin, Hossein, and Anderson: Comparing the Value of Nonprofit Hospitals’ Tax Exemption to Their Community Benefits

6 KelloggInsight, Healthcare research, What Happens to Healthcare Costs When Nonprofit Hospitals Take a Financial Hit?

 
George Suttles

Author

George Suttles

Executive Director

Disclaimer

Certain information contained herein has been obtained from or is based on third-party sources and, although believed to be reliable, has not been independently verified. Such information is as of the date indicated, if indicated, may not be complete, is subject to change and has not necessarily been updated. No representation or warranty, express or implied, is or will be given by The Common Fund for Nonprofit Organizations, any of its affiliates or any of its or their affiliates, trustees, directors, officers, employees or advisers (collectively referred to herein as “Commonfund”) or any other person as to the accuracy or completeness of the information in any third-party materials. Accordingly, Commonfund shall not be liable for any direct, indirect or consequential loss or damage suffered by any person as a result of relying on any statement in, or omission from, such third-party materials, and any such liability is expressly disclaimed.

All rights to the trademarks, copyrights, logos and other intellectual property listed herein belong to their respective owners and the use of such logos hereof does not imply an affiliation with, or endorsement by, the owners of such trademarks, copyrights, logos and other intellectual property.

To the extent views presented forecast market activity, they may be based on many factors in addition to those explicitly stated herein. Forecasts of experts inevitably differ. Views attributed to third-parties are presented to demonstrate the existence of points of view, not as a basis for recommendations or as investment advice. Market and investment views of third-parties presented herein do not necessarily reflect the views of Commonfund, any manager retained by Commonfund to manage any investments for Commonfund (each, a “Manager”) or any fund managed by any Commonfund entity (each, a “Fund”). Accordingly, the views presented herein may not be relied upon as an indication of trading intent on behalf of Commonfund, any Manager or any Fund.

Statements concerning Commonfund’s views of possible future outcomes in any investment asset class or market, or of possible future economic developments, are not intended, and should not be construed, as forecasts or predictions of the future investment performance of any Fund. Such statements are also not intended as recommendations by any Commonfund entity or any Commonfund employee to the recipient of the presentation. It is Commonfund’s policy that investment recommendations to its clients must be based on the investment objectives and risk tolerances of each individual client. All market outlook and similar statements are based upon information reasonably available as of the date of this presentation (unless an earlier date is stated with regard to particular information), and reasonably believed to be accurate by Commonfund. Commonfund disclaims any responsibility to provide the recipient of this presentation with updated or corrected information or statements. Past performance is not indicative of future results. For more information please refer to Important Disclosures.

Stay connected with the Insights Blog

Popular Blog Posts


Market Commentary | Insights Blog

Chart of the Month | The Surprising Relationship Between Money Supply and Inflation

The potential for rising inflation is becoming a top concern for many investors and consumers. Many believe that inflation is already here as evidenced by price increases in commodities, homes,...
Perspectives | Insights Blog

The Case for Using the Higher Education Price Index® (HEPI) to Define Inflation for Colleges

When calculating return targets for an endowment portfolio, a conventional piece of the equation is often the Consumer Price Index (CPI). CPI plus 5% is the common short-hand formula for institutions...
Market Commentary | Insights Blog

Chart of the Month | U.S. Budget Deficit Hits Record Highs

In his first 100 days as President of the United States, Joe Biden has introduced three domestic funding proposals, totaling close to $6.0 Trillion, reflecting a desire to enhance the role of the...

Disclaimer

Certain information contained herein has been obtained from or is based on third-party sources and, although believed to be reliable, has not been independently verified. Such information is as of the date indicated, if indicated, may not be complete, is subject to change and has not necessarily been updated. No representation or warranty, express or implied, is or will be given by The Common Fund for Nonprofit Organizations, any of its affiliates or any of its or their affiliates, trustees, directors, officers, employees or advisers (collectively referred to herein as “Commonfund”) or any other person as to the accuracy or completeness of the information in any third-party materials. Accordingly, Commonfund shall not be liable for any direct, indirect or consequential loss or damage suffered by any person as a result of relying on any statement in, or omission from, such third-party materials, and any such liability is expressly disclaimed.

All rights to the trademarks, copyrights, logos and other intellectual property listed herein belong to their respective owners and the use of such logos hereof does not imply an affiliation with, or endorsement by, the owners of such trademarks, copyrights, logos and other intellectual property.

To the extent views presented forecast market activity, they may be based on many factors in addition to those explicitly stated herein. Forecasts of experts inevitably differ. Views attributed to third-parties are presented to demonstrate the existence of points of view, not as a basis for recommendations or as investment advice. Market and investment views of third-parties presented herein do not necessarily reflect the views of Commonfund, any manager retained by Commonfund to manage any investments for Commonfund (each, a “Manager”) or any fund managed by any Commonfund entity (each, a “Fund”). Accordingly, the views presented herein may not be relied upon as an indication of trading intent on behalf of Commonfund, any Manager or any Fund.

Statements concerning Commonfund’s views of possible future outcomes in any investment asset class or market, or of possible future economic developments, are not intended, and should not be construed, as forecasts or predictions of the future investment performance of any Fund. Such statements are also not intended as recommendations by any Commonfund entity or any Commonfund employee to the recipient of the presentation. It is Commonfund’s policy that investment recommendations to its clients must be based on the investment objectives and risk tolerances of each individual client. All market outlook and similar statements are based upon information reasonably available as of the date of this presentation (unless an earlier date is stated with regard to particular information), and reasonably believed to be accurate by Commonfund. Commonfund disclaims any responsibility to provide the recipient of this presentation with updated or corrected information or statements. Past performance is not indicative of future results. For more information please refer to Important Disclosures.