Do Bear Markets Favor Active or Passive Investing? It Depends.

April 6, 2020 |
2 minute read

In the ongoing debate about active versus passive investing, conventional wisdom posits that active investing outperforms passive in recessionary or bear market environments. The question is: Will the expected pattern hold up in the current sell-off and what will almost assuredly be the ensuing recession? The answer: it depends.

Thus far in the present market environment it has not been true. That’s because what it depends on is the structure of the sell-off, how long it lasts and how much forced selling takes place. In the bear market of 2001-02, for example, the sell-off was not rapid, there wasn’t a lot of forced deleveraging and individual stocks responded to underlying fundamentals. That environment worked for active fund managers. When markets decline slowly—not suddenly as is the case currently—active managers tend to hold more cash (which, granted, can be called market timing) and they may also hold more defensive securities. On the other hand, a quick, hard-hitting bear market is characterized by significant deleveraging, correlations that go way up and stocks trading on liquidity more than anything else. It’s a sell-what-you-can environment. There were days recently when utilities were down more than the market—not what one would ordinarily expect.  

The chart below shows the correlation of various stock sectors in the U.S. Typically, correlations are between 0.3 and 0.6,  reflecting price discovery and  market participants’ evaluation of the fundamentals of sectors and underlying companies. That environment provides active managers with the opportunity to use their research skills to identify winners and losers and, hopefully, add value for investors on both the upside and the downside. Further, the chart also shows that sector correlations during the recent sharp equity market plunge rose to 0.9 as investors sold indiscriminately.


This is an environment that doesn’t work well for active managers, hedging or relative value strategies. Fundamentals simply take a back seat when stocks that are not even impacted by the virus are down 20, 30 percent or more in just a few days. While this is negative, of course, it does set up opportunities to capture alpha going forward. That’s what happened in the recovery of 2009, after the 2011 retrenchment and in the immediate wake of the Brexit referendum. What will lead us out of this is managers that can stay the course and take advantage of attractive pricing opportunities and benefit when the market starts to incorporate data and fundamentals into stock prices.  And while we don’t know where and when those attractive opportunities will present themselves, they most assuredly will.  Lastly, we also draw comfort from working with long-tenured managers who have demonstrated an ability to weather prior downturns and, eventually, benefit when the market environment begins to turn.

Mark Bennett


Mark Bennett

Managing Director

Mark Bennett


Kristofer Kwait

Chief Market Strategist

Stay connected with the Insights Blog

Popular Blog Posts

Market Commentary | Insights Blog

Chart of the Month | The Surprising Relationship Between Money Supply and Inflation

The potential for rising inflation is becoming a top concern for many investors and consumers. Many believe that inflation is already here as evidenced by price increases in commodities, homes,...
Perspectives | Insights Blog

The Case for Using the Higher Education Price Index® (HEPI) to Define Inflation for Colleges

When calculating return targets for an endowment portfolio, a conventional piece of the equation is often the Consumer Price Index (CPI). CPI plus 5% is the common short-hand formula for institutions...
Governance And Policy | Insights Blog

Endowment Management and the Three Primary Responsibilities of a Board

The fourth blog in the “Six Ps of Investment Stewardship” series addresses People, specifically how boards function within an organization. To learn more about the first four principles in the series...


Certain information contained herein has been obtained from or is based on third-party sources and, although believed to be reliable, has not been independently verified. Such information is as of the date indicated, if indicated, may not be complete, is subject to change and has not necessarily been updated. No representation or warranty, express or implied, is or will be given by The Common Fund for Nonprofit Organizations, any of its affiliates or any of its or their affiliates, trustees, directors, officers, employees or advisers (collectively referred to herein as “Commonfund”) or any other person as to the accuracy or completeness of the information in any third-party materials. Accordingly, Commonfund shall not be liable for any direct, indirect or consequential loss or damage suffered by any person as a result of relying on any statement in, or omission from, such third-party materials, and any such liability is expressly disclaimed.

All rights to the trademarks, copyrights, logos and other intellectual property listed herein belong to their respective owners and the use of such logos hereof does not imply an affiliation with, or endorsement by, the owners of such trademarks, copyrights, logos and other intellectual property.

To the extent views presented forecast market activity, they may be based on many factors in addition to those explicitly stated herein. Forecasts of experts inevitably differ. Views attributed to third-parties are presented to demonstrate the existence of points of view, not as a basis for recommendations or as investment advice. Market and investment views of third-parties presented herein do not necessarily reflect the views of Commonfund, any manager retained by Commonfund to manage any investments for Commonfund (each, a “Manager”) or any fund managed by any Commonfund entity (each, a “Fund”). Accordingly, the views presented herein may not be relied upon as an indication of trading intent on behalf of Commonfund, any Manager or any Fund.

Statements concerning Commonfund’s views of possible future outcomes in any investment asset class or market, or of possible future economic developments, are not intended, and should not be construed, as forecasts or predictions of the future investment performance of any Fund. Such statements are also not intended as recommendations by any Commonfund entity or any Commonfund employee to the recipient of the presentation. It is Commonfund’s policy that investment recommendations to its clients must be based on the investment objectives and risk tolerances of each individual client. All market outlook and similar statements are based upon information reasonably available as of the date of this presentation (unless an earlier date is stated with regard to particular information), and reasonably believed to be accurate by Commonfund. Commonfund disclaims any responsibility to provide the recipient of this presentation with updated or corrected information or statements. Past performance is not indicative of future results. For more information please refer to Important Disclosures.