Episode 12
In this episode of Commonfund Point of View, Julia Mord, Chief Investment Officer of Commonfund OCIO, sits down with Mark Hoeing, President and CEO of CF Private Equity, to walk through the private equity trends shaping fall 2026. Mark explains how the rate reset since 2022 has changed the math for buyouts. Leverage and multiple expansion once did much of the work, and today returns depend far more on real earnings growth. He describes a K-shaped fundraising recovery, where capital is concentrating with managers who have delivered returns, and explains why distributions have lagged. He also sees cautious optimism that 2026 exit activity could be among the strongest years on record.
The conversation then widens to AI, Europe and venture capital. Mark treats AI first as a diligence question about the durability of each company’s moat, and then as a source of margin improvement across portfolios. He makes the case for Europe’s more fragmented, less richly priced markets, and explains why the power law in venture rewards the small group of managers with consistent access to winning companies. Julia and Mark close on the illiquidity premium, which Mark says is largely gone except among top-quartile managers and is now something investors have to earn. He finishes with where investors are leaning in: the lower middle market, early-stage venture, secondaries and co-investments, and energy.
Welcome to Common Fund Point of View. I'm Julia Mord, Chief Investment Officer of Common Fund OCIO. In this podcast, we'd like to give you our latest views on capital markets and investing in fifteen minutes or less. Today, I'm joined by Mark Howing, President and CEO of CF Private Equity and Head of the firm's Buyout and Growth Equity Investment Practices. Mark, why don't we take a step back? Since 2022, rates reset and the cheap financing playbook stopped working. How has that changed the math for private equity, and what does it mean for companies financed under the old regime? Well, good morning, Julia. Thanks for having me. I think the headline is that in the prior iteration of buyout returns in particular, leverage, cheap debt, and multiple expansion used to do half the work. And now that's been virtually eliminated and growth really needs to drive returns. So post 2022 and the interest rate increase in the prior iteration or before the regime change, it was possible to generate a two and a half times return, compounding EBITDA at about 5% using available capital market tools. Well, that's all changed. And today, you really need about 12% compounded annual EBITDA growth to generate a similar type return given that rates are so much higher, cost of capital is so much higher. And I think the scars of all that really show up in portfolios that were built between 2016 and 2020. And many of those companies, when the interest rate increase happened, if they had not yet been realized, you know, showed about a 60% reduction in overall value. And that showed up and hit many portfolios. So I think going forward, the regime change means you really have to rely on growth to drive return and less so on financial engineering. The other trend is fundraising. Fundraising, as you know, has slowed dramatically. What does that mean for managers and where do you expect the shakeout to happen? I think the headline on fundraising is that capital isn't disappearing. It's really concentrating. So we see that concentration in what I would call a K shaped financing or fundraising recovery. The top of the K are managers who have delivered return. They tend to be those managers focused more on growth, less on use of leverage, more focused on disciplined entry prices and operating improvement of companies, really fundamental company building. And so some of the statistics today show that managers who have delivered top quartile performance in the current past cycle are raising capital about a 90 plus percent rate, while other managers below the top quartile are raising at 40% odds. So you're seeing that recovery among managers that have proven an ability to generate returns, not necessarily relying on financial engineering and much more around company building, buy and build opportunities. And we see a real edge among first institutional capital into private companies, buying from founders, buying from entrepreneurs, corporate carve outs in particular. And so the fundraising market, I think, will continue to show a bifurcation and a concentration among managers that have delivered in the prior cycle. On a similar note, the other end of the spectrum, distributions. And distributions have also slowed considerably. They've been a pain point, particularly for LPs. So the question mark is what will drive a real pickup? And if we reflect on the distributions in twenty twenty five-twenty six, how much of that activity came from continuation vehicles and secondary sales rather than traditional exits? And then on that note, guarding traditional exits, what's your view on the pickup of M and A activity? Yeah, the last question first and I can The work headline from our perspective is that we're cautious on timing with a shade of optimism around exits. It does feel like 2025 showed a recovery in exit activity. The first part of 2026 was really, impaired by what happened with the war in the Middle East. And that has started to pick up again in 2026. So it feels like to me every two years, we now have a new hiccup, whether that was COVID, supply chain recovery, increase in interest rates, implementation of tariff policy, every two years it seems like it's throwing another wrench into the system. That said, I do think 2026 will show it could be the second largest exit year on record, particularly since the last peak of 2021. So, we're cautiously optimistic and we're seeing signs that a recovery in exit activity is happening. That said, if we go back in time, the pain has been real for investors. You know, when it comes to distributions, historically, private equity returns had delivered somewhere between 2025% of the prior year's NAV in distributions, and that really slowed down to about 15% during, call it, the 'twenty three, 'twenty four, 'twenty five period. So significantly below what the historical averages were. It actually rhymes a bit. If we go back to the GFC, we saw a period of two to three years where something very similar happened. Distribution slowed down as a percent of NAV, you had valuation adjustments at the same time where assets that had been accreting in value paused or even declined in value, and it took time to work through the I think for the current kind of marketplace and what will it take for a recovery to happen, think you need to see several things happen. One is more confidence coming from buyers of companies around interest rate policy, around tariff policy, around kind of overall macro conditions. I also think another part of it will be, okay, once that happens and there's more confidence, I think you'll start to see financial buyers, strategic buyers more willing to step in and have more confidence on entry value. And so, that also will require, I think, a reset in the minds of private equity owners around taking the pain from the prior cycle. They've been kicking the can down the road in many cases, and so taking the pain around buyer and seller expectations on valuation is an evolving process. So when all that comes together, you'll start to see a more systematic recovery in distributions and exit activity for private equity owners. Now we can't have a podcast on private equity and not talk about AI. So, how are you thinking about AI disruption in our underlying portfolio companies? Is it a threat to moats or is it an opportunity for margin expansion or at least margin protection? I think AI risk for private equity owners and for allocators is really a it's kind of a it's at first a diligence question, and then it's a margin enhancement question. What I mean by that from a diligence perspective is looking at asset by asset kind of dynamics and the situation with every company. So I don't think you can paint this one with a broad brush. Going asset by asset, the diligence question is really around what is the moat of the underlying business as it relates to their IP, their systems? Is that moat vulnerable to kind of an AI native next set of businesses that will come in and kind of disrupt that moat? That's kind of the diligence question. I think from a margin enhancement tool perspective, we're seeing every private equity and venture manager out there implementing AI tools in their companies. And it is driving operational improvement, particularly around coding, particularly around hiring expensive engineers, every business, whether it's an old line traditional industrial business or a new line kind of tech first business, all of them are benefiting from kind of the margin enhancement available by using AI tools. I think we'll continue to see that happen. And so in both respects, I think investors need to be prudent about identifying moats and how sustainable those moats are at the business level to things like AI risk. Let's turn our attention to Non US. Common Fund has a presence internationally. We do screen for and look for opportunities both in Europe and Asia. Can you talk about the opportunity set Ex US and particularly in Europe today? Sure. I think in Europe, and as you point out, we've got 40 investment professionals that focus only on the private markets with some of those professionals in Europe and Asia. And I think Europe is more fragmented. It's shown kind of less hype around price. It's demonstrated kind of recent exit activity has been pretty significant. And so I would expect that the playbook outside The US is actually being implemented and opportunistically attractive given what's happened in The US, which I think, in particular in technology, you've had so much hype on entry prices over the last several years. Outside The US, we see better prices, more fragmentation, and then the sourcing channels to find these businesses and these companies, particularly those that are family owned, that are entrepreneur owned, where you can be first institutional capital investing into those companies, You just see much more local sourcing to find those companies. And then as we're entering them, we do see more attractive entry prices. And so I think the dynamic outside The US has exhibited less of that hype and managers have been able to be more disciplined and demonstrate, particularly in 2026, we've seen a higher level of exit activity out of our European portfolio. And I think that'll continue. And the fragmentation can't be understated. I think there are a lot of companies that operate quite well in particular geographies, whether that's The Nordics, whether it's German speaking Europe, a bit of the French speaking Europe. Entrepreneurs build these companies and as they grow and become available for private equity to invest in, they're highly fragmented about where they're demonstrating operating performance. So a good private equity partner can come in, team up with an existing owner, and grow those businesses across The US, in particular outside of Europe, so take regional companies and make them global, which we think that thesis makes a lot of sense. Let's turn our attention to venture capital. As we know, in venture, a handful of power law companies such as OpenAI, Stripe, ByteDance, Anthropic, Amderel are all raising ever higher valuations, and at the same time capturing a disproportionate share of the total value in the ecosystem. Given that, how should investors think about the asset class when so much value just accrues to so few companies? Yeah, maybe just a comment on the power law because people talk about this a lot. We see it in the numbers. In the venture backed ecosystem, when a company was sold in the early 2000s, they were typically a billion dollar valuation, a $1,000,000,000 valuation was a highly attractive exit point. That increased to about $10,000,000,000 in, call it, the late 2010s. That's now moved today to a $40.50, 60,000,000,000 kind of exit value. And so you're seeing power law or exponential growth in the value of venture backed companies as they move to exit. So that power law is very real. What the trouble with it is it also is compounded by the fact that it's very few companies that are driving most of the return in the venture backed ecosystem. And so getting access to those companies and having reliable and consistent access to those companies at the earliest stages is very important. And so access to those companies is usually found through a very persistent set of early stage venture managers. And so that data moves from companies to managers where you're seeing a few companies drive the return. It's a very concentrated set of managers that are consistently in those companies. And that makes it difficult for institutional investors to access that part of the market consistently. Punchline is we think there is a structural advantage among a certain set of managers that have proven an ability to actually concentrate capital into the winning companies. And it's just harder and harder if you're not in that cohort of managers. I also want to talk about the liquidity premium or the illiquidity premium in the industry. As you know, if you look at the last three years of data, I think it shows that the illiquidity premium is largely gone. The exception is top quartile managers, right? Given the large dispersion of returns within private equity, we are seeing that they are producing an illiquidity premium. Given that, it does beg the question, does the diversification case still hold in private equity, and how should investors approach manager selection? Yeah, I think the punchline on the liquidity premium or the illiquidity premium, said the other way, is it's not a it's no longer a gift to the industry. It now has to be earned. If we back up to the prior cycle, I think a larger swap of managers were generating a sufficient illiquidity premium. And that gift is now gone for the reasons we've just talked about, which I would argue requires diligence around what is the source of return, where has return been generated. And in this regime change environment that we're currently operating in, that liquidity premium, I think, will be more scarce. And we're seeing that in the data. To your point, yes, upper quartile venture managers, upper quartile private equity managers, even some in the high second quartile in private equity, so in the buyout space, they're continuing to compound their returns at rates that do generate the illiquidity premium for investors. Accessing that is really one of the most important jobs. I think it's getting harder to do that in a lot of ways because persistence of return has become less prevalent among managers against this backdrop. And so finding that illiquidity premium requires, I think new models of looking at data, being able to analyze at the company level where returns are coming from, acknowledging the fact that I think the GP led continuation market, which is today, I think, a very viable tool rather than kind of an opportunistic tool, and that having general partners wanting to ride their winners or invest behind their winners in the next cycle through a GP led continuation event requires a lot of asset by asset screening among LPs. And I think for LPs, that's traditionally a skill set that they've lacked to be able to analyze company by company what the prospects of a business are. And so, I think in order to earn that illiquidity premium in the future, it's going to require LPs to be much more proactive about analyzing the opportunity set. So, one last question, Mark. Given all that we just discussed, where are private equity investors leaning in today, given the opportunity set? I think private equity managers today in kind of fall twenty twenty six, we're seeing much more investment in the lower end of the middle market and buyouts where there's a real structural advantage around pricing, historically not a large use of leverage, driving returns, and an opportunity to build companies when buying from entrepreneurs and first time kind of institutionally backed private companies. We're seeing investors lean into early stage venture capital where the persistence of return among a small set of managers continues to be the feedstock for building companies that ten to fifteen years later become the next set of drivers of return. And we're seeing several of those returns in the industry today across companies like SpaceX, which is now public, Anthropic, which is supposed to go public this week As two current examples. And it's really been the private company staying private longer thesis and compounding returns in the private markets against the backdrop of shrinking public markets that has been a really persistent and diversified kind of opportunity set for investors. In addition to that, we see the secondaries market, the co invest market as really tactical opportunities to concentrate capital at value entry points, into entry points where you have a high level of conviction because of information arbitrage coming out of knowledge of private companies and private financing events, which come from a large book of existing private assets. And so, being able to tactically price those things are very attractive in today's market where there's fundamentally a bit of a mismatch between supply and demand in favor of tactical kind of value oriented entry points. And then finally, I'd say across energy, for the first time in more than a decade, we're seeing structural growth in energy coming from not just AI and the requirement of power demands associated with AI, but also security and the security mega theme. So, we're seeing more and more companies garnering investment and coming out of the private side of things from entrepreneurs focused on kind of security of energy supply, security of overall kind of megatrend around energy. And so, we think those are the areas that managers are leaning in attractively against today's kind of backdrop of opportunity. Well, Mark, thank you so much for your insightful thoughts on private equity and venture capital. That concludes our podcast. Please join us next quarter for our next episode of Point of View.
View the full playlist and subscription options for this podcast here.
